Detection and Prevention

of Milking Routine Problems by Computerized Monitoring of Milking Irregularities

R. Ginsberg 1 , D. Rak 2 , A. Arazi 2 , and E. Aizinbud 2
1 National Service for Udder Health and Milk Quality – Israel Dairy Board, Yehud, Israel
2 Afimilk, Kibbutz Afikim, Israel

Electronic computer monitoring of herd and individual cow performance is common in Israeli dairy herds, and allows characterization and quantification of milking efficiency as well as parlor throughput.

Eicker et  al.  (2000)  theorized  that  computerized  parlor  data  could  be  used  to  monitor  how milkers used the equipment in the parlor. The advantage of ACR compared with manual removal is well known. One of milking routine violations is “overriding” of the ACR settings.

Historically cows were considered milked out when the milk flow rate decreased to 200 gr/min and most ACR’s were set to this level. Sagi 1978 and Rasmussen 1993 concluded that the cluster can be detached at a flow rate of 400 gr/min with no negative effect on the milk yield. Milking time was also significantly shorter.

Between 1997 and 2002 Steward together with various associates showed the effects of gradually raising take off settings with similar results.

A  study  was  carried  out  to  examine  if  computer  monitoring  of  the  dairy  herd  can  help  in  the assessment of the milking routine on individual farms, to advise on possible shortcomings, and to monitor  recommendations  on  improvements  to  the  milking  routine,  particularly  violations  of “overriding” the ACR settings.

Materials and Methods

A survey was conducted at 30 randomly selected farms using the milking “Irregularities Report” of the  Afimilk  management  software  system  (SAE  Afikim,  Kibbutz  Afikim,  Israel)  to  monitor:  1. Irregular take-offs – kick-offs or milker intervention. 2. Slow cows – Cows milking longer than 8 minuets. 3. Low flow time removal (Low milk flow was classified as less than 1 kg (2.2lb)/min).

Default ACR settings for Afikim milk meters in Israel are 0.48kg (1.05 lb) milk/min.

All  farms  were  monitored  for  ten  consecutive  days  prior  to  the  study.  Milking routine was monitored visually with an emphasis on the milkers’ experience and skill. Farms with extreme milking irregularities were instructed on optimum udder preparation and not to manually override the automatic take-off settings.

Milking irregularities as determined in a survey

On one of the herds surveyed milkers routinely canceled the manufacturers default ACR settings resulting in irregular take-offs considerably higher than the average. Milkers were instructed not to “override” the ACR and to reattach the cluster only if the milk meter indicated that the cow had milked less than the designated minimum percent of milk per milking. Results were immediate and unmistakable.

Milking irregularities as determined in a survey
DHi date begore and after the changing the milkinf routine


Results of this survey showed large variations in milking irregularities with many of the herds overriding the ACR settings. The findings of this field study in commercial herds support the results of previous studies indicating that default ACR settings can be set at 0.48 kg (1.05 lb) milk/min with no detrimental effects on milk yield, udder health and milk quality. Computer detection of milking irregularities at one of the herds showed that it was possible to improve parlor performance and other shortcomings resulting from overriding ACR settings. Computerized monitoring in the milking parlor provides a data base for a fast and efficient clarification of milking irregularities. This data base can be used to correct the reasons for these phenomena and monitor the results. 


Eicker, S., S. Stewart, D. Reid, and P. Rapnicki. New tools for measuring the effect of stimulation and take off on milk flows. Proc. Annual Meeting of the National Mastitis Council. 127-133, 2000.

Rasmussen,   M.D.   Influence   of   switch   level   of   automatic   cluster   removers   on   milking performance and udder health. Journal of Dairy Research 60(3):287-297. 1993.

Sagi,  R.  Milk flow rate and end of milking detectors.  Proc.  Annual Meeting of the National Mastitis Council. 328-334 1978.

Stewart, S.C., et al. Effects of automatic cluster remover settings on average milking duration, milk flow, and milk yield. Journal of Dairy Science 85(4):818-823. 2002.